James Frey Again (Despite My Better Judgment)
And if a poll isn't enough for ya', leave a comment -- and then, depending on what box you checked, read the Guardian's spoof on the new book.)
Reader Question: Book on Revising a Novel?
I wrote back: "I had similar problems with my book and found it helpful to turn to classic works of literature that have things in common with my book to see how they did it. Since your book is very plot-oriented, you might try something like Pride and Prejudice. Jane Austen puts her reader at the heart of the plot immediately, and yet the dialogue's so revelatory that you never feel anything's missing in terms of character development. (If dialogue isn't your strong suit, look around for another writer who shares your strengths, to see how they use them.)
"Francine Prose has a good book about how to read books for this purpose. I know this sounds like a much more labor-intensive way of learning, but I don't know of a how-to book that really answers this question."
And yet screenwriters have Story, which seems to basically do this. I wanted to turn this question to a wider audience, in part to see if others had books that had helped them. But I also wondered if, as creative writers, we really want a formula? Screenplays have to be somewhat formulaic, right, but do we really want that for our novels?
Writing Spaces
Every summer I look over our lists of writers' rooms to make sure everthing's current, and I was pleased this year to see that not one had closed -- it seems these spaces are surviving, if not downright flourishing, at least in urban areas. And this summer, we even had two new spaces to add, WriterHouse in Charlottesville, VA, and Ditmas Workspace, pictured here, in Brooklyn, NY. Call for Submissions: West Goes South
Reader Question: Do I Need Permission?
My response to Rose was that no permission is needed for describing major landmarks. Publishers worry about things like images, poetry, and trademarked names. And should there be some question, the publishers will have their legal people take a look. Unless it's a major part of your book -- like say, your main character is a doll named Barbie -- let them pay to do the research, and concentrate your efforts on getting the book written and published.
But in this litigious age, it doesn't hurt to be informed. Columbia University has a good copyright site, courtesy of their Copyright Advisory Office. More information is also available on the U.S. copyright office site.
But there are plenty of resources out there. If you have tips -- or if you have your own experiences with copyright questions -- please give them up below. And of course feel free to peruse other reader questions here.
Best Writing Advice?
All of this got me wondering what advice About.com readers might have. What's the best advice you've ever received about writing? Pass it on in the comments below.
Press 53: North Carolina Indie Publisher
You've got to love a press that has "Really Fab Books" running at the top of their home page. Which is one of the many reasons I was pleased to learn about Press 53, a small publisher of literary fiction, poetry, and nonfiction. With the mainstream publishing industry about to cough up its last lung, I'm convinced these small, savvy, passionate presses are going to save the soul of American literature. (Pick up the interview with novelist Garth Stein in this month's Poets and Writers for an example of how they not only save souls, but careers.) If you've got a book that's been rejected by the corporate presses -- or you just want to discover some new good books -- read more about Press 53 and other independent presses.Profile and Review of the Journal Mānoa
A friend of mine in Hawai'i introduced me to Mānoa ten years ago and then sent me the most recent issue, Maps of Reconciliation, this spring, which led me to profile it next for the list of smaller journals (though with a subscriber base of 2,500, Mānoa isn't that small). Mānoa brings the voices of Asia, the Pacific, and the Americas to English-speaking readers. In this day and age, such sources are obviously more important than ever -- and Mānoa is so well-crafted that exploring it is a pleasure, as guest reviewer Gay Davis notes.Making an Author Study
I've done this twice before, with Raymond Chandler and Eudora Welty, and both times I took something away. How-tos are fine, but there's something to be said for seeing what worked for others, and understanding exactly why.

